FICTION — Rock Ptarmigan News Service
MAPLE RIDGE, Ill. — A 13-year-old Scout asked troop leaders Sunday to reverse several years of advancement and return him to Webelos Scout status after arriving at a weekend campout without a sleeping bag.
The request came shortly after 7:30 p.m. at Camp Arrow Pine, when members of Troop 417 began setting up tents and discovered that eighth-grader Nolan Price had packed two flashlights, rain gear, a stove, a compass, three pairs of socks, and no item designed specifically for sleeping.
“I was not prepared,” Price said in a statement delivered from inside a borrowed fleece liner. “I don’t think I can in good conscience continue at my current rank.”
Scoutmaster Kevin Dorsey told Price that advancement does not work in reverse and that the appropriate response to forgetting equipment is to solve the immediate problem and remember it next time.
Price reportedly found this explanation “procedurally weak.”
By 8 p.m., he had drafted a handwritten request titled Voluntary Rank Reassessment Following Preparedness Failure.
“He came to me and said, ‘I think we need to look at Webelos,’” Dorsey said. “I told him Webelos is a Cub Scout rank for younger Scouts and also that ‘Webelos’ isn’t used by itself like a job title. He said that actually made the demotion feel more serious.”
Current Scouting terminology uses Webelos Scout for a Cub Scout in the Webelos program. This did not discourage Price.
He spent the remainder of the evening voluntarily repeating basic tasks he believed he had “prematurely moved beyond,” including tying knots, reviewing a packing checklist, and asking another Scout to observe him correctly roll a sleeping pad.
“Nolan already knows how to do all this,” said fellow Scout Mateo Ruiz. “That’s why this is taking so long.”
The situation broadened Saturday night after two other Scouts quietly checked their own packs for forgotten gear and began asking whether advancement could be audited retroactively.
One Scout discovered he had failed to bring toothpaste.
Another had packed toothpaste but no toothbrush.
For approximately fifteen minutes, Troop 417 appeared to face what adult leaders described as “a confidence event.”
Dorsey called a brief meeting.
“I told them the whole point of learning preparedness is to become more prepared over time,” he said. “It is not a legal doctrine where one missing sock invalidates your entire childhood.”
Price’s father, Eric, said his son has always taken the Scout motto seriously.
“Last year he forgot a spoon and ate chili with a cracker,” he said. “He still brings that up.”
By Sunday morning, Price had reorganized his backpack into labeled zones and produced a new two-page packing system with checkboxes, verification initials, and a final line reading SLEEPING BAG PHYSICALLY OBSERVED.
Adult leaders did not approve the form for troop-wide use.
They did, however, borrow several ideas.
The missing sleeping bag did not create a safety problem. Price slept in loaned gear supplied by troop leaders, and temperatures remained mild.
Dorsey said that was the more important lesson.
“Preparedness also means a group can adapt when somebody makes a mistake,” he said. “Nobody had to spend the night proving a point.”
At the closing meeting Sunday, Price withdrew his demotion request after what he described as “a successful remedial camping performance.”
He declined to say whether he now considered himself restored to good standing.
“I’m taking it one trip at a time,” he said.
As the troop loaded vehicles, Price completed his new departure checklist.
He confirmed his sleeping bag was present.
He then left the checklist itself on a picnic table.
Related: Orienteering Merit Badge Group Fails to Return From Orienteering Exercise · An Interview With a Bird That Declined Identification · A Bear Locker Full of Questions
Leave a Reply